Quarterly Market Commentary: When Navigating Uncertainty, Confidence Comes from Preparation

Quarterly Market Commentary: When Navigating Uncertainty, Confidence Comes from Preparation
Sarah Bomhoff, CFA, CIPM
April 3, 2025
Quarterly Commentary

When hiking in Colorado, bring a rope.

I say this from hard-earned experience that was a little too close for comfort. The first lesson came when my son slipped off the trail, catching himself at the last possible moment, hanging on by his fingertips. The second came just four months later when my father lost his footing in nearly the same way. That time, it took a harrowing 12-hour rescue to bring him to safety.

Market Performance:

The market, like our Colorado hiking adventures, feels a bit more slippery than it felt just 3 months ago.  During the 1st Quarter, US Equities experienced a pullback, while fixed income provided stability as interest rate expectations shifted.

  • S&P 500 Total Return Index (U.S. Large Cap Equities): Lost -4.27% in Q1 but remains up 8.25% over the past 12 months.
  • MSCI ACWI NR Total Return Index (Global Equities): Declined -1.32% in Q1 but remains up 7.15% over the last year.
  • Bloomberg Global Aggregate Total Return Index (Fixed Income): Rose 2.64% in Q1, up 3.05% over the past 12 months.

Charting the Path: Q1 Challenges

  • Trade Tensions: A Period of Realignment - The current administration’s trade policies have introduced new complexities into global markets. Tariffs and supply chain adjustments are creating uncertainty for some industries, while others have proven more resilient. Looking to Q2, the April 2nd Tariff announcements are creating widespread recalibration and present a potential headwind in the coming months.
  • Inflation: A More Nuanced Picture - While inflation remains elevated, recent data has been mixed. The Consumer Price Index (CPI) peaked in February before cooling in March, and wholesale inflation (PPI) showed similarly uneven trends. The Federal Reserve is taking a measured approach, balancing inflation control with economic stability.
  • Labor Market: Signs of Cooling, Not Cracking - The labor market remains a key indicator of economic strength. Job growth has slowed, but unemployment remains within a historically healthy range. While some businesses are scaling back hiring plans due to policy uncertainty, demand for skilled labor continues in key industries.
  • Interest Rates & The Fed: Policy Flexibility in Focus - The Federal Reserve maintained a steady stance in Q1, keeping interest rates unchanged as it assesses inflation risks and economic conditions. Futures markets suggest the possibility of rate cuts later this year, but timing remains uncertain, as policymakers remain cautious in their approach.
  • Consumer Sentiment: A Shift in Spending Behavior - Consumer confidence weakened in Q1, reflecting concerns about inflation and economic uncertainty. That said, spending patterns remain resilient in select areas, such as travel and luxury goods, bolstered by higher earners. While sentiment metrics have softened, certain sectors continue to see strong demand.
  • International Exposure: Selective Opportunities in a Shifting Landscape - With uncertainty in U.S. markets, international diversification was meaningful last quarter, with the MSCI ACWI ex US NR Index returning a positive 5.23%. While global economies face their own challenges, certain regions, particularly in Europe, pulled their weight last quarter

Staying on Solid Ground: Confidence in the Plan

When my son slipped off the trail, we didn’t have a rope. But we did have something else. Our family dog, who instinctively ran beneath him, giving him just enough support to regain his footing. When my father lost his step months later, he didn’t have a rope, but other preparations made all the difference. He was wearing sturdy hiking gloves, allowing him to grip the rocky terrain. He was able to call for help, ensuring rescue teams knew where to find him. And he had enough hiking experience to find two solid rocks to stabilize himself until help (and ropes) arrived.

In both moments, the missing rope was legitimate cause for fear, but because of other preparations, the rope’s absence did not change our family story.

This is the essence of a well-structured investment strategy. It’s impossible to predict every twist and turn in the market, but a strong plan doesn’t rely on one single factor; it is built with multiple layers of resilience, allowing one part to pick up the slack for the lack of the other.

During the first quarter, the market didn’t have the “rope” that has been the US Technology. That segment of the market, as represented by the NASDAQ 500 Sec/Information Technology Total Return Index, was down -12.65% in the quarter. Positive returns in other parts of the market, including US Large Cap Value stocks, International Stocks, and the bond markets helped portfolios keep their footing. Specialized strategies that limit stock downside risk or allow for asymmetric returns also did well last quarter, buffering out some of the downside volatility.

Periods of market complexity draw attention to sophisticated, well-structured approaches. The path can seem slippery, and we all miss the rope from time to time. But just as preparation, experience, and the right tools made all the difference on the trail, a resilient investment strategy keeps a single challenge from derailing long-term goals. Volatility and uncertainty will come, but with a steady hand and a disciplined plan, they do not need to change your story.

The S&P 500 Index is a market capitalization-weighted stock index. It is comprised of about 500 stocks of the largest capitalization companies that are traded on U.S. stock exchanges.
The MSCI ACWI Net Index measures the performance of large and mid-cap companies across 23 Developed Markets and 27 Emerging Markets. The MSCI ACWI® Net Index subtracts foreign taxes applicable to US citizens.
The Bloomberg US Aggregate Bond Index measures the return of investment grade debt across the US market.
All returns are reported assuming that interest, capital gains, and dividends are reinvested.
Past performance is not indicative of future results.

For disclosures, please click here.

Quarterly Market Commentary: When Navigating Uncertainty, Confidence Comes from Preparation

Sarah leads our investment committee to shape our investment choices and manages our portfolios.